2 Tasty Toffee - Old Saybrook, cT

retail locations

Atlantic Seafood

1400 Boston Post Rd - Old Saybrook, CT

Saybrook Country Barn

2 Main St - Old Saybrook, CT

Sweet Lunas (Toppers)

139 Main St - Old Saybrook, CT

The Chocolate Shell

18 Lyme St - Old Lyme, CT

The Lyme Tree

86 Halls Rd - Old Lyme, CT

Starfish Market

650 Village Walk - Guilford, CT

Sweet Emotions

9 Dog Lane, 106B - Storrs, CT

Fairfield Women's Exchange

332 Pequot Ave - Southport, CT

Greenwich Women's Exchange

28 Sherwood Place - Greenwich, CT

Shoreline Prime Meats & Deli

103 North Main St - Branford, CT

The Skincare Studio

454 Main St - Durham, CT

Red House Gifts

redhousegifts.com - Madison, CT


673 Boston Post Rd - Madison, CT

NV Bakery & Market

40 Boston Post Rd - Waterford, CT

toffee Made to order in small batches

To ensure that our customers get a fresh, quality product all our toffee is hand made in small batches. 2 Tasty Toffee is a toffee business based in Old Saybrook CT. 

We strive to put out an exceptional product at a fair price. Toffee makes great gifts for holidays or any occasion. Birthdays, Valentine's Day, Thanksgiving or Christmas, candy gifts are perfect! Special packaging and party favor options available upon request. 

We believe that our toffees and related products are the best tasting on the market.


Place an Order

New FLAVOR!  Look what the storm blew in:

HurricaneCrunchy almond toffee with a wave of milk chocolate and a sprinkle of sea salt covered with a cloud of toasted marshmallow and coconut then drizzled with both dark and white chocolate. A surge of flavors that will blow your taste buds away!

Look what's new

Gifts for everybody on your list!  Who doesn't love handmade toffee!  


Teacher Gifts

They LOVE our toffee!  Small boxes are perfect for any occasion to show your appreciation.


Like us!